No. SA-18-CV-60-XR · W.D. Tex. · August 19, 2019 · Judge Xavier Rodriguez
What happened
A customer tripped over a pallet at the entrance to a Wal-Mart garden center in November 2016 and later had knee surgery. A preservation directive asked for the surveillance video within days, but by January 2017 internal records said the video appeared to be lost. Scene photos and witness statements were also missing.
What the court did
Judge Rodriguez held that the duty to preserve arose by December 28, 2016, when the customer told Wal-Mart’s claims manager she intended to pursue a claim. He found that Wal-Mart failed to take reasonable steps to preserve the video and that it could not be replaced. He rejected intent to deprive, so no adverse inference or dismissal under Rule 37(e)(2). But he found prejudice: without the video, the plaintiff could not show how long the pallet sat there. As the curative measure under Rule 37(e)(1), he barred Wal-Mart from asserting or arguing comparative negligence, including that the danger was open and obvious. He also ordered Wal-Mart to pay fees for two motions and court reporter fees for two depositions.
Why it matters
- A curative measure can be tailored to exactly what the video would have shown, and still decide the case.
- Telling the claims manager you intend to pursue a claim can start the duty to preserve.
- Internal preservation directives mean little if no one confirms the footage was actually saved.
Source: Bellamy v. Wal-Mart Stores Texas, LLC, opinion. Summary only, not legal advice; read the decision.