No. 2:17-cv-13061 · E.D. Mich. · January 10, 2019 · Magistrate Judge Anthony P. Patti
What happened
A man was struck by a freight door at a Wal-Mart in Roseville, Michigan, in October 2016. The store’s video retention period was about 30 days. An asset protection manager saved the interior camera footage, which showed an employee lowering the door, but not the exterior camera, and could not recall why. Counsel’s notice letter arrived within the retention window.
What the court did
The court found Wal-Mart was on notice from the day of the incident, pointing to its own accident-investigation policy, which called for obtaining video, and its claim form, which told employees to preserve evidence. Selectively preserving one angle was not a reasonable step. The lost exterior view would have shown the plaintiff’s perspective, the heart of Wal-Mart’s open-and-obvious and comparative-fault defenses. The court inferred intent to deprive from the selective preservation and ordered, under Rule 37(e)(2)(B), that the jury must presume the exterior footage was unfavorable to Wal-Mart unless it withdrew those defenses. It compared offering the jury “only a single, interior view of the incident” to giving a referee one replay angle.
Why it matters
- Saving the clip that looks relevant is not enough. Preserve every angle.
- A company’s own investigation policy can fix the date of notice at the incident itself.
- Intent to deprive can be inferred from what was kept and what was not.
Source: Culhane v. Wal-Mart Supercenter, opinion and order. Summary only, not legal advice; read the decision.