No. 22-1377 · 2d Cir. · February 13, 2025
What happened
In a § 1983 excessive-force case against Yonkers police officers, the taser log showed two deployments, but video existed only for the second. Testimony indicated the first video had been overwritten, with no further explanation. The trial court declined to instruct the jury that it could draw an adverse inference, and the jury found for the officers.
What the court did
The Second Circuit affirmed. It held that an adverse-inference sanction under Rule 37(e)(2) requires a finding that the party acted with intent to deprive the other side of the information’s use in the litigation, and that the lesser negligence-based standard from its pre-2015 case law no longer applies to lost ESI. It held that intent must be proven by a preponderance of the evidence, not clear and convincing evidence, and that the court may decide the question itself or leave it to the jury.
Why it matters
- In the Second Circuit, as in the majority of circuits, an overwritten video alone will not get an adverse inference.
- The fight is over evidence of intent: who knew about the video, when, and what they did.
- Curative measures under Rule 37(e)(1) remain available on a showing of prejudice.
Sources: Hoffer v. Tellone, Second Circuit opinion; Cleary Gottlieb summary. Summary only, not legal advice; read the decision.