No. 19-cv-50135 · N.D. Ill. · May 19, 2022
What happened
The plaintiff asked the employer, in writing, to view security video of what happened, then filed a complaint and a charge of discrimination. CEVA's security recordings were normally kept for 30 to 90 days before being deleted automatically. The video was not preserved.
What the court did
Judge Johnston started from Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37(e), the sole source for addressing lost ESI. He found the video was lost, the plaintiff was prejudiced, and CEVA failed to take reasonable steps to preserve it. He left intent to the jury, noting the failure could have been unintentional. Instead of sanctions, he ordered curative measures: factual findings about the spoliation will be read to the jury, with an instruction on how it may use them. The findings cover the plaintiff's requests to see the video, CEVA's inaccurate statements about who had the footage, and a supervisor's earlier review of footage from an unrelated incident.
Why it matters
- A written request to see footage can trigger the duty to preserve.
- Even without a finding of intent, a jury can hear exactly how the footage was lost.
- A 30 to 90 day retention window isn't long once a complaint is in.
Source: Hollis v. CEVA Logistics U.S., Inc., opinion (via Sidley). Summary only, not legal advice; read the decision.