Home / Case law / Nagy v. Outback Steakhouse

D.N.J. · 2024 · Premises

Nagy v. Outback Steakhouse

The cameras ran on a seven-day loop and only clips were kept. The court found intent to deprive, so the jury may presume the lost footage was unfavorable.

2024 WL 712156 · D.N.J. 2024

What happened

A plaintiff fell at an Outback restaurant. The restaurant's surveillance system overwrote its footage every seven days. Outback kept a short clip, then about 27 minutes around the fall: roughly five and a half minutes before it and about 22 minutes after. The rest of the day was overwritten.

What the court did

The plaintiffs moved for spoliation sanctions. The court found that Outback had a duty to preserve, failed to take reasonable steps, and acted with intent to deprive the plaintiffs of the footage. It granted the motion in part: the jury may be told that Outback intentionally failed to preserve the video and may presume the lost footage was unfavorable to Outback. A separate request about a missing incident report was denied because no formal report existed.

Why it matters

  • Keeping "the relevant clip" isn't enough when the rest of the day could matter.
  • A seven-day loop leaves almost no time. Preservation has to start the day of the incident.
  • Rule 37(e)(2) adverse-inference instructions are on the table when a court finds intent.

Source: eDiscovery Assistant case review (LexBlog). Summary only, not legal advice; read the decision.

Talk to a specialist

Footage on a loop? Talk to a video evidence specialist today.

Tell us where the cameras are. We will tell you what to preserve, how to collect it and how fast it needs to happen.