Home / Guides / Authentication

Authentication

How to authenticate surveillance video

Rule 901 asks you to show the video is what you say it is. Rule 902(14) lets a hash-verified copy do much of that work on paper. Here is how both apply to footage.

Short answer

Either a witness testifies that the video is what you claim, or, for a digital copy, a qualified person certifies under Rule 902(14) that its hash matches the original. Both are far easier when the footage was exported natively, hashed at collection and logged at every hand-off.

Rule 901: the baseline

Federal Rule of Evidence 901 requires evidence sufficient to support a finding that an item is what its proponent claims. For surveillance video that usually means one of two things: a witness who saw the events testifies the footage fairly shows them, or someone explains how the camera system records and how the copy was made, so the system itself vouches for the picture. With footage of an empty loading dock at 2 a.m., there is often no eyewitness, and the second route is the only one.

Rule 902(14): hash-verified copies

Since December 2017, Rule 902(14) has made certain copies self-authenticating: data copied from an electronic device, storage medium or file, if authenticated by a process of digital identification and certified by a qualified person under the requirements of Rule 902(11) or (12), with the same advance notice (Fed. R. Evid. 902(14); text and committee note).

The committee note explains that copied data is ordinarily authenticated by hash value, and that when the original and copy have the same hash it is “highly improbable that the original and copy are not identical” (committee note). The note also says the rule is flexible enough to allow other reliable methods. The Federal Judicial Center describes 902(13) as covering records generated by an electronic process or system and 902(14) as covering electronic copies.

For video, 902(14) fits the most common situation: the original lives on a recorder that will be overwritten, and what reaches the case is an exported copy. Hash the export when it is made, and every later copy can be checked against it.

What a certification does not do

A 902 certification establishes authenticity and nothing else. The committee commentary notes it can establish only that the item satisfies the admissibility requirements for authenticity (Esquire Deposition Solutions). The other side can still argue the clip is incomplete, misleading or irrelevant, and the jury still decides what weight it gets. Authenticity also does not answer questions about the recorder’s clock; that needs its own record.

The record that makes it work

A qualified person can only certify what was documented. Build the record at collection:

  • Native export first, with the player, as SWGDE’s DVR guidance recommends. See how to export DVR footage.
  • SHA-256 at the moment of export, recorded with the file name and size.
  • Re-verify on arrival and at every transfer, and log who, when and how.
  • Clock offset: the difference between the recorder’s clock and a reference time, so every camera lines up.
  • Recorder details: make, model, settings and the export method used.

SD Preserve builds this record as the footage moves. The custodian’s browser computes a SHA-256 fingerprint before upload, the server recomputes it on arrival, the recorder clock offset is captured in the same portal, and every event lands in a hash-chained custody log. Read about our evidence handling.

Common questions

What is a hash value?

A short string computed from a file’s contents. Change one bit of the file and the hash changes, so matching hashes show a copy is identical to the original.

Does a Rule 902(14) certification make video admissible?

It establishes authenticity only. The other side can still object on relevance, prejudice or other grounds.

Which hash algorithm should we use?

SHA-256 is the common choice today. Rule 902(14) does not name an algorithm and allows other reliable methods.

Related

Talk to an expert

Footage on a loop? Talk to a video evidence expert today.

Tell us where the cameras are. We will tell you what to preserve, how to collect it and how fast it needs to happen.