Short answer
If video that should have been preserved is lost because a party did not take reasonable steps, and it cannot be replaced, the court may order measures to cure the prejudice. The harshest remedies, a presumption that the video was unfavorable, an adverse-inference instruction, or dismissal, require a finding that the party intended to deprive the other side of it.
The rule
Rule 37(e) was rewritten in 2015 to give federal courts one framework for lost electronically stored information. Its text (Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(e)):
If electronically stored information that should have been preserved in the anticipation or conduct of litigation is lost because a party failed to take reasonable steps to preserve it, and it cannot be restored or replaced through additional discovery, the court:
(1) upon finding prejudice to another party from loss of the information, may order measures no greater than necessary to cure the prejudice; or
(2) only upon finding that the party acted with the intent to deprive another party of the information’s use in the litigation may: (A) presume that the lost information was unfavorable to the party; (B) instruct the jury that it may or must presume the information was unfavorable to the party; or (C) dismiss the action or enter a default judgment.
Video is ESI
Digital surveillance footage is electronically stored information, so Rule 37(e), not a court’s inherent authority, governs its loss in federal court. The court in Tripp v. Walmart collected decisions reaching that conclusion and applied Rule 37(e) to lost store footage.
The four threshold questions
Before any remedy, the moving party has to show four things, as the court summarized in Fowler v. Tenth Planet:
- The party had a duty to preserve the video.
- The video was lost.
- It was lost because the party failed to take reasonable steps to preserve it.
- It cannot be restored or replaced through additional discovery.
Replacement is often where video cases turn. Another camera angle, a saved clip or a forensic recovery from the drive can defeat the motion, which is why a single preserved angle can still leave a party exposed if the lost angle showed something different.
Curative measures under (e)(1)
With prejudice but no intent to deprive, the court can order measures no greater than necessary. Courts have been creative with video:
- In Bellamy v. Wal-Mart (W.D. Tex. 2019), the store lost video of a trip over a pallet. The court found no intent but real prejudice, and barred Wal-Mart from arguing comparative negligence or that the danger was open and obvious.
- In Hollis v. CEVA Logistics (N.D. Ill. 2022), the court ordered its factual findings about how the video was lost read to the jury.
Intent to deprive under (e)(2)
The severe remedies need a finding that the party acted with intent to deprive. Negligence is not enough. In Hoffer v. Tellone, 128 F.4th 433 (2d Cir. 2025), the Second Circuit held that intent must be shown by a preponderance of the evidence, that the court or the jury can decide it, and that the old negligence standard no longer applies to lost ESI (Cleary Gottlieb summary). There, video of the first of two taser deployments had been overwritten without explanation, and the court affirmed the refusal to give an adverse-inference instruction.
Intent can be inferred from circumstances. In Culhane v. Wal-Mart (E.D. Mich. 2019), the store saved the interior camera but not the exterior one, and could not say why. The court inferred intent from the selective preservation and ordered that the jury must presume the lost footage was unfavorable unless Wal-Mart withdrew its comparative-fault defenses.
When the duty to preserve starts
The duty attaches when litigation is reasonably anticipated, and video cases show how early that can be:
- A written request to view the footage helped trigger the duty in Hollis.
- In Bellamy, the duty arose when the injured customer told the claims manager she intended to pursue a claim.
- In Culhane, the store’s own accident-investigation policy, which called for obtaining video, supported notice from the day of the incident.
State courts
Rule 37(e) governs federal court. State courts apply their own spoliation law, and some allow sanctions for negligent loss. In a 2026 slip-and-fall decision, New York’s Second Department held that destroying video of the fall warranted a sanction because the defendants were at least negligent, and that an adverse-inference charge, rather than precluding all defense evidence on liability, was the right one (New York Appellate Digest).
What to do with this
- Requesting the video: send the preservation letter immediately and keep proof. It fixes the date of notice.
- Holding the video: preserve every angle over a wide window, not the one clip that looks relevant, and document what you kept and why.
- After a loss: get the retention settings, the overwrite date and who reviewed the footage before it was lost. Track decisions in our case law tracker.
Common questions
Is surveillance video ESI under Rule 37(e)?
Courts generally treat digital surveillance footage as electronically stored information, so Rule 37(e) governs its loss in federal court.
What is the difference between Rule 37(e)(1) and (e)(2)?
Subdivision (e)(1) allows measures no greater than necessary to cure prejudice. Subdivision (e)(2) allows a presumption, an adverse-inference instruction, dismissal or default, but only on a finding of intent to deprive.
Is negligence enough for an adverse inference over lost video?
Not in federal court under Rule 37(e)(2). The Second Circuit held in Hoffer v. Tellone (2025) that intent to deprive is required and must be shown by a preponderance of the evidence. State courts apply their own law.